Rethinking Readability Scores: Part 1

Alt: A doodle shows a document to a second doodle with cat head. The document reads, “Your skull be felined.” The first doodle says, “Oooohhhh yeah! Got this baby down to a sub-second grade reading level!”

Readability scores can give health communicators an immediate sense of accomplishment. Who among us hasn’t been pleased to say, “My material went from an 11th grade reading level to a 6th”? It may be tempting to rest on our readability laurels, but what does a reading grade level really tell us?

Unfortunately, not much. Readability formulas use the number of syllables, words, or sentences in a document to calculate a score in the form of a grade level, like 10th grade. This means that, theoretically, your audience needs at least a 10th grade reading level to understand your content.

And that’s exactly what the score is — theoretical. If you take that same document and score it using 3 different readability formulas, you’ll get 3 different scores. And they may range from 8th grade up to 14th. Not all that helpful, is it?

That’s because a grade level readability score is not a measure of health literacy. Short sentences with short words are just that — short. They’re not necessarily understandable, actionable, interesting, or useful to your audience.

In other words, readability scores can miss a lot. They don’t assess whether your material:

  • Uses words that your audience understands
  • Uses easy-to-read fonts and numbers in a clean design
  • Has a tone that’s appropriate for your audience
  • Includes images that connect to your main messages
  • Takes your audience’s knowledge and experiences into account

Our advice: focus on the factors that help your audience understand and use your material, and readability will follow.

So, if readability formulas are flawed, why do so many people keep using them? Great question! Check out Rethinking Readability Scores: Part 2 to get the answer.

The bottom line: Skip the grade level readability formulas and focus on making edits that will help your readers understand and use your content.

Tweet about it: What’s wrong with readability scores? @CommunicateHlth shares tips for going beyond grade level to assess #HealthLit materials: https://bit.ly/2WoerUy

 

Browse recent posts

Do you heart health literacy? We sure do! Sign up to get practical health literacy tips and tricks — delivered to your inbox every week.